Removal of Conditions
A conditional permanent resident must file the petition to remove condition on green card in Form I-751 before their two year green card expires. Failure to timely file the petition may result in loss of lawful permanent resident and potential removal proceedings.
Haranlaw assists conditional permanent residents nationwide specifically in Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers and throughout Indiana with timely and properly documented I-751 filings including joint petitions and waiver cases.
Marriage-Based Removal of Conditions
Conditional residents who obtained their two-year green card through marriage must file Form I-751 jointly with their petitioning spouse unless a waiver of joint filing applies. This includes children who received conditional permanent residence through their parents' marriage and derived permanent residence under family-based immigration.
Investment-Based Removal of Condition (EB-5)
In EB5 investment cases, when a green card is issued for two years, the investor must apply to remove the condition from the green card. The applicant must show to the USCIS that the investment enterprise has been sustained and all EB-5 program requirements including the job creation, have been met.
If the conditions are successfully removed in either of the above cases, the government issues a ten-year permanent resident card. USCIS must determine that the marriage was entered in good faith and remains genuine, or that the EB-5 investor has complied with all applicable investment and job-creation requirements.
EB-5 investors must also file petition to remove conditions to receive a ten-year permanent resident card.
The Process
The foreign national must file the petition to remove conditions in Form I-751. Late filing is common and can be excused under circumstances.
The Form I-751 petition is typically filed jointly by both spouses. In some cases, USCIS may schedule an interview if facts require additional screening although interviews are discretionary. Many petitions are approved without an interview.
Joint filing of removal of conditions petition is not always possible. In cases involving divorce, legal separation, death of the petitioning spouse or abuse, the conditional resident foreign national can seek a waiver of joint filing requirement. Additional information regarding I-751 filing timelines and waiver categories is discussed below.
When to File Form I-751
Form I-751 must generally be filed within the 90-day period before the conditional green card expired.
Late-filed Form I-751 may be accepted if the conditional resident demonstrates good cause and extenuating circumstances for the delay. Because late filing puts the applicant's permanent resident status at risk, careful review of filing deadlines is critical.
I-751 Waiver of the Joint Filing Requirement
Although Form I-751 is typically filed jointly, a conditional resident may request a waiver of the joint filing requirement when joint filing is not possible.
A waiver may be requested based on:
-
Divorce or annulment of the marriage
-
Death of the petitioning spouse
-
Battery or extreme cruelty by the petitioning spouse
-
Extreme hardship
Each waiver category has distinct legal standards and evidentiary requirements, and the burden is on the applicant to establish eligibility.
Risks
Removal of conditions is a proceduraly and evidentially demanding process that requires careful attention to timing and documentation.
Whether the conditional resident spouse files Form I-751 jointly or requests waiver as a sole applicant, the core issue in USCIS inquiry remains the same, i.e., whether the marriage was genuine and not entered for the purpose of evading immigration laws. If USCIS finds fraud, it could have serious and lasting immigration consequences and makes it difficult to overcome.
If the spouses are separated or divorced or when the spouse is controlling and abusive, often the petitioning spouse is non cooperative and joint filing is not possible. The foreign national spouse becomes so distraught that (s)he loses the ability to think clearly or present a well-documented I-751. It is good to take the help of a knowledgeable immigration attorney at this stage to ensure that the petition is well framed and supported.
Importantly, a failure to prove marriage bona fides does not automatically mean the marriage is fraudulent, but USCIS frequently mixes up lack of evidence with a finding of fraud.
Denials of removal of condition for misrepresentation or fraud or for any other reason terminates conditional residence and exposes the individual to possibility of deportation, also known as removal.
Conditional permanent residents require careful planning in filing the petition to removal of conditions from green card. Mistakes in filing can lead to delays, interviews or even initiation of removal proceedings. Because I-751 cases often involve complex evidentiary issues, many applicants seek guidance from experienced immigration attorney before filing.
When legal help is the better option:
- Problems in marriage or separation
- Divorce
- Insufficient joint documents
- Prior immigration problems
- Interview scheduled by USCIS
- Late filing
Denial of Removal of Conditions
USCIS denials of Form I-751 may be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). However, appeals involving allegations of misrepresentation or marriage fraud are subject to heightened scrutiny.
If a conditional resident is placed in removal proceedings before the Immigration Court, the Immigration Judge may review the denial and has authority, in appropriate cases, to remove the conditions on permanent residence.
Termination of permanent resident status can be avoided when the conditional resident acts timely and appropriately to preserve immigration status and presents sufficient evidence to establish eligibility.
Removal of conditions, like any other immigration filing is not merely a form-filling process. In each marriage based case, the agency inquiry is very fact specific and filing standard documents are no longer considered sufficient. Each case requires careful documentation and legal analysis based on what is appropriate under the individual circumstances to establish eligibility and compliance.
Because removal of conditions involves strict deadlines and fact-specific legal standards, conditional residents should address potential issues early and ensure that their filings are well prepared. Consulting an experienced immigration attorney can help ensure that the petition is properly completed and supported.
How Haranlaw Helps
Conditional resident applicants seeking to remove conditions on permanent residence at Haranlaw, receive personalized guidance . Representation may include:
• Careful review of filing eligibility and deadlines
• Strategic preparation of joint or waiver filings
• Evidence organization and legal framing
• Response to Requests for Evidence (RFEs)
• Interview preparation where required
Clients work directly with the attorney. Based in Carmel and serving clients throughout Indianapolis and Indiana, Haranlaw assists individuals and families in preparing and filing removal of conditions petitions and addressing related immigration concerns.